Back in 2016, METALLICA‘s original manager revealed to Metal Hammer magazine that the band briefly considered making Ulrich its frontman.

Jon “Jonny Z” Zazula, who started working with METALLICA before the release of the band’s debut album, “Kill ‘Em All”, recalled James Hetfield‘s lack of confidence in handling lead vocal duties. As a possible solution, it was suggested that Ulrich could step up from the drum stool to the microphone.

Zazula told Metal Hammer: “Lars and I planned a lot of stuff. But James wasn’t the most confident of singers. I don’t think he felt comfortable.

“At one point there was even talk of Lars becoming the frontman. For about five seconds.”

Other singers who were being considered for the frontman position in METALLICA included Jess Cox of Newcastle, England’s TYGERS OF PAN TANG and John Bush of ARMORED SAINT (and later ANTHRAX), who actually turned the offer down.

Bush later said in an interview: “METALLICA did ask me to join, but I said no for all the right reasons. People must think that’s crazy, but you have to remember the scene then. METALLICAwas nobody. ARMORED SAINT was hot; you have to remember that. Also, I was very tight with the [ARMORED SAINT] guys, back to elementary school in fact. ARMORED SAINT was getting interest from all kinds of places, and we had a lot of people starting to turn up at shows.”

He continued: “METALLICA came to see SAINT at a gig in Anaheim, at The Woodstock in 1982. I heard they were interested in asking me to join, which they did later. The thing was that METALLICA was this new kind of thing, and nobody back then. I don’t care what they say now; nobody could have predicted what would happen. I didn’t know the guys either, so there was no real interest. It was great to be asked — in fact, a lot of people asked — but ARMORED SAINTwas really strong.

“Some time after ‘Kill ‘Em All’ had come out, I heard the same thing again, but I never understood that because James was singing great then and he was doing a great job. I understood the lack of confidence back in ’82 but not for ‘Ride The Lightning’. James owns that record.”

In a 1989 interview with Metal Forces, Ulrich talked about what METALLICA could have sounded like had Bush ended up fronting the group. He said: “Only a couple of days ago, we were actually sitting around talking about how it would be now if John Bush had joined the band. Obviously, it’s impossible to know how different it would have been, but I can’t imagine METALLICA without James Hetfield up there growling into the microphone, fucking curved over and everything. It’s really weird to think about it. I mean, nothing against John Bush — I think he’s a great vocalist — but … Well, thank God it didn’t happen.”